Choir of Angels (Red)
View in Room

Create your first list.

A way to share and manage lots.

  • Provenance

    Gallery Pilsner, Paris
    Acquired from the above by the present owner

  • Exhibited

    London, Chinese Contemporary Gallery, Liu Ye and Mao Yan, 2000

  • Literature

    Sconfinamenti, exh. cat., Chinese Contemporary, London, 1999, p. 25 (illustrated)
    N.N., ‘Untitled’, Today 1 (2000) (illustrated on the cover)
    Christoph Noe ed., Liu Ye: Catalogue Raisonné 1991-2015, Berlin, 2015, no. 99-09, p. 288 (illustrated)

  • Catalogue Essay

    Chinese contemporary painter Liu Ye is known for his dream-like imagery inspired by his childhood love of fairytales and formative education in Europe, giving rise to a singular body of work rich in aesthetic, historical and literary meaning. Distinguished from his fellow Chinese painters by a prevailing love of wonder and mystery, Liu Ye’s bold and meditative paintings challenge viewers to participate in a world liberated from the concrete and the present.

    Childhood memory, fairy tales and European influence


    Giorgio de Chirico
    The Disquieting Muses, 1916
    Born in Beijing two years before the Cultural Revolution began, Liu grew up in a society rigidly controlled by the state. Liu Ye's father was a famous children’s playwright, and although many Western books were banned at the time, his parents had secreted a trove of Western story books in a large black chest under his bed, including the works of Hans Christian Andersen and Tolstoy. Liu Ye became an imaginative child, and this quality combined with the manner of his upbringing in China would later prove a key source of his inspiration and way of seeing: ‘In my earlier days, [inspiration] came from my imagination, childhood memories, and the societal background’ (Liu Ye, quoted in Cheryl Zhao, ‘Artist Liu Ye on His New Catalogue Raisonné and the Rise of Chinese Collectors’, Jing Daily, 10 December 2015, online).


    René Magritte
    Clairvoyance, 1936
    Liu Ye’s knowledge of Western cultural history was formulated during the years he spent in Europe. In 1990, having completed his studies in mural painting at the Central Academy of Fine Arts in Beijing, Liu Ye continued his studies for another four years at Berlin's Universität der Künste, and then took up a six-month residency at the Rijksakademie in Amsterdam in 1998. During these years Liu Ye became influenced by European artists such as Piet Mondrian (whose grid-based paintings became a recurring motif in his paintings), Dick Bruna (in particular his iconic creation Miffy), as well as René Magritte, the Belgian Surrealist. Explaining why he was drawn to these artists, Liu Ye elaborated: ‘In my earlier days, my art was more about the imaginary. At that time, I was influenced by Italian Metaphysical Art and Surrealism; René Magritte is one of my favourite artists’ (Liu Ye, quoted in Cheryl Zhao, ‘Artist Liu Ye on His New Catalogue Raisonné and the Rise of Chinese Collectors’, Jing Daily, 10 December 2015, online).


    Borrowing from fairy tales and artistic encounters in Europe, the guileless characters with tiny cherub wings emerged to occupy the spotlight in Liu’s paintings. Depicting these childish figures on theatre stages or in landscapes, fully immersed in their own worlds and unaware of the concurrent catastrophic scenes of sinking ships and flying bombers (see for example in Bright Road, 1995), the artist has imbued a deliberately humorous yet ridiculous mood in his works, injecting a sense of Surrealism and irony.

    The curtain sets the stage

    Chorus is one of Liu Ye’s earliest paintings and part of his iconic ‘red curtain’ series, which was executed shortly after his return from Europe to China. The ‘red curtain’ paintings nod to the carefully balanced, methodical compositions of René Magritte and Georgio de Chirico, which saw objects and scenes depicted in a realistic yet unsettling manner. Their preference for Classically-inspired forms and volumes (see for example the fluted columns in de Chirico’s The Disquieting Muses, 1916) echo the modelling and theatricality of Liu Ye’s red curtain motif. The unique composition of the present lot features eleven cherubic singers, which was later rendered in shades of blue and re-created into lithography by Liu Ye in the early 2000s.

    The curtain is a double-edged symbol: it acts to reveal, immediately recalling to mind Balthus’ The Room (within Liu’s oeuvre for example, please see the warship in Untitled, 1997-8) and yet its primary function is to conceal. In this scene, the emotionless singing cherubs are arranged neatly to project a sense of order and discipline so unusual among a group of boisterous children that this harmonious imagery appears to be deceiving. Speaking of the persistent human desire to question reality and appearances, Magritte explained: ‘We are surrounded by curtains. We only perceive the world behind a curtain of semblance. At the same time, an object needs to be covered in order to be recognised at all’ (no citation available). Rich in evocative mystery, the curtain becomes an enduring motif in Liu’s works to create a profound sense of spatial and temporal dislocation, the interplay of truth and illusion teases with preconditioned perceptions of reality and conventional ways of seeing.

    Atelier
    1991, acrylic and oil on canvas
    Atelier is the first piece that Liu Ye recognises in his oeuvre, portraying Andy Warhol next to the canonical image of Mao Zedong in a classically tinged interior view. The shade of red that colours the drapery and the skirt of the figure is used more extensively in his works after his return from Europe in 1995. Beijing Madonna
    1994-5, acrylic and oil on canvas
    The artist's earliest thematic treatments of the theatre stage begin in Beijing Madonna (1995), in which he parodies operas and stage shows of the bygone revolutionary era. The red curtain takes on the role similar to a stage prop and acts as a backdrop to the winged choir singers, the scene conveys a distinct sense of order that is slightly subverted by the breast feeding ‘Madonna’ in the front that conveys an erotic and jocular feeling. Bright Road
    1995, acrylic and oil and canvas
    Bright Road showcases Liu’s typical form of expression, the distant sky covered by heavy clouds and marked by the smoke trail of a bomber, in the foreground two cherubs play carelessly. The artist exposes the disparity between the innocence of childhood life and a socio-political reality that some may find suffocating. Commenting on the possibility to disconnect individual life with the real world, the unconcerned ignorance of the dancing cherubs symbolises the artist’s reluctance to politicise his works. Untitled
    1997, acrylic and oil and canvas Sold for HK$5,860,000 at Phillips Hong Kong
    The first time Liu Ye addressed the motif of the red curtain was in Untitled (1997), in which it was elevated to assume the role of a protagonist in its own right. The circular shape of the spotlight is set against the squared composition, leaving the main character in focus. The depiction of the curtain as a symbolic act of concealing takes on additional meaning as a way of self-discovery. Untitled
    1997-8, acrylic and oil and canvas
    The red curtain was given more significance in his naval ship series, in Untitled (1997-98), this recurring motif not only acts as a concealments device, it also separates reality and illusion. The stage locates the viewers in a fictional world as the spotlight shines on the innocent and unconcerned young singers. The boy sailor turns his back to the audience as he parts the curtain to reveal a towering battleship, shattering the comfort of the artist’s fictional construction. Poet
    1997-8, acrylic and oil and canvas
    The artist returns to theme of the stage in Poet (1999), a classic large scale work, the period saw one the artist’s most important development with the frequent utilisation of the colour red. The red stage curtain with a cluster of oval floodlights mirrors the circle in square composition of the present lot, partly derived from the circular fade-outs in silent film, this visual setting provides a circular window-like focal point to capture the close up of his characters, insinuating hidden drama unfolding beneath the seemingly calm surface.


    A world ‘covered up in red’

    The rich crimson red which colours the backdrop and subjects of Chorus adds another layer of meaning. A signifier of joy and luck in Chinese culture, the colour red was also transformed irrevocably into an ideological colour monopolised by revolutionary propaganda: the Chinese national flag ‘dyed red’ by the blood of revolutionaries, the Red Army of the Communist Party, the red scarf worn by the Young Pioneers, and the ‘red heart’ of party loyalists and supporters of socialism: ‘I grew up in a world that was covered up in red – the red sun, the red flag and red scarves. As for green pines and cedars, or sunflowers, they were usually just foils for the symbolism of red,’ recalled Liu Ye. Associating the colour red with the prevailing visual emblem of his childhood days, the singing cherubs in Chorus subtly references the rosy-cheeked children featured in popular propaganda, while the stage setting and the deployment of a rounded spotlight dramatically amplify the theatrical effect of the imagery.

    Interestingly, the red and blue renditions of Chorus both speak to a visual experience triggered by childhood memory, as the artist recalls using coloured pencils with ‘red for the sun and the national flag, yellow for sunflowers and sunlight, and blue for the ocean and sky.’ These represent Liu’s earliest use of primary colours that extends to his paintings to emphasise a personal experience within a collective society. The transition from one dominant colour to another mirrors Pablo Picasso’s shift from his Blue Period to Rose Period – from depicting a state of poverty and rejection to finding love and companionship - it corresponds to the psychological states prompted by tragedy, love, relationship within the social conditions of the time. For Liu, red is a tool of reminiscence that reconnects the artist’s memory with his homeland, and the development to blue presaged a period of more internal exploration into a more abstract form of expression.

    Yet Chorus does not dwell on the past – Liu’s time in Berlin came at a crucial moment in Chinese modern history, allowing him to develop his work independent of political developments back home. The stage, once associated with the plays of his father and subsequently the ‘red’ propaganda of revolutionary operas, is instead concealed in Chorus by a curtain which draws a symbolic close on history. The assembly of singers with faces of rotund childlike innocence points to nostalgic reflection on childhood experience. Liu Ye liberates symbols of the past using the power of imagination and fairy tales, allowing new meanings and associations from both Eastern and Western cultural traditions to interact freely in the theatrical red curtained setting. In this sense Chorus is a symbol for the artist himself – liberated to investigate the intersections of history and representation, Liu Ye has developed a distinct visual vocabulary that transcends traditional Eastern and Western art historical categories.

    The artist was recently the subject of a solo exhibition at Prada Rong Zhai, Shanghai (2018 - 19), and his works are held in numerous public collections, including the Long Museum (Shanghai), M+ Sigg Collection (Hong Kong), and Today Art Museum (Beijing). The artist is represented by David Zwirner.

Select Language

English

中文

Ο ◆ ✱ Ж7

Property from an Important Collection

Liu Ye

Choir of Angels (Red)

1999
signed and dated 'Ye [in Chinese] liu ye 99' lower right
oil on canvas
169.1 x 199.2 cm. (66 5/8 x 78 3/8 in.)
Painted in 1999.

Estimate
HK$20,000,000 - 40,000,000 
€2,290,000-4,570,000
$2,560,000-5,130,000

sold for HK$27,750,000

Contact Specialist

Charlotte Raybaud
Head of Evening Sale, 20th Century & Contemporary Art

+852 2318 2026

CharlotteRaybaud@phillips.com

20th Century & Contemporary Art Evening Sale

Hong Kong Auction 8 July 2020